Are musicians born or made?

This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.
Over the years, as more and more people begin to realize the
importance of music, more music schools start to exist to involve and educate
people musically. However, if one were already born with that gift for music,
would one still have to go through such musical trainings? Take for instance,
Mozart; did he have to go through any of that? Till date, many are still
debating over this topic. Following this debate, I would like to introduce a
very good read, ‘Origins of Western Music, Essay Nr 36: Are Musicians born or
made?’ by David Whitwell, who is a PhD holder in musicology and a guest
lecturer in many universities.
Whitwell contends that musicians are both born and made. He states how hard
work is important as in the case of Beethoven who puts in a lot of effort for
his compositions and had the gift of knowing what to
reject. Mozart on the other hand was different as
he was gifted in music. Turning to an argument on 'Nature versus Nurture' through other Renaissance writers, there are other factors that are important for a musician as well. Pieto
Artino, an important Renaissance writer, believes that "neither the gift
nor the skill is of any importance without heart.” Johann
David Heinichen, a philosopher and composer in Dresden, believes that the
gift and knowledge of music are interlinked because knowlege is created by the
gifted themselves. Musicians should have the flair for music, should be able to
work hard, and should possess at least the fundamental theories required of
music. Another very important German writer, Johann
Mattheson not only shares the same stand, but also adds on that sometimes
people possess talents which are not yet perfected.
In my humble opinion, musicians are not people with just gifts
or the skills, but those with the heart to play music; after all, ‘music’
played without the heart can never truly be music.
Reference:
Whitwell, David, “Essays on the
Origins of Western Music, Essay Nr 36: Are Musicians Born or Made?” whitwellessays.com.
<Whitwellessays.com/docs/DOC_932.doc>